The Story of Edgar Sawtelle Summary & Key Insights

David Wroblewski's "The Story of Edgar Sawtelle" unfolds as a coming-of-age tale narrated by a mute protagonist, Edgar, set against the backdrop of a Wisconsin kennel breeding champion Border Collies. Edgar, born into a family with a deep connection to their dogs and a history of selective breeding, shares a unique bond with his canine companions, understanding and communicating with them at a level surpassing typical human-animal interaction. His father, Arthur, is a renowned dog breeder and a stern, sometimes cruel figure who instills a similar discipline in Edgar, further isolating him due to his inability to speak. His mother, a mysterious and melancholic presence, worships dogs to an almost obsessive degree and dies under ambiguous circumstances, leaving a profound impact on both Edgar and Arthur.

The story progresses through Edgar's development, showcasing his unique skills in training and understanding dogs, mirroring his own quiet observation of the human world. He forms a strong bond with his loyal Border Collie, Augusta, who becomes a crucial part of his emotional life. The family's business, Sawtelle Kennels, flourishes under Arthur's hand, yet darkness lurks beneath the surface. Jealousy, betrayal, and unspoken resentments simmer within the community, all intricately tied to the dogs and their lineage.

The central conflict revolves around the mysterious death of Arthur. Suspicion falls on different members of the community and Edgar himself, and the investigation becomes interwoven with the complex history of Sawtelle Kennels and its dogs. The narrative is punctuated by flashbacks, revealing Arthur's past dealings, hinting at his potentially ruthless tactics in dog breeding and business, as well as his strained relationship with his son. These flashbacks shed light on the reasons behind Edgar’s unique relationship with dogs, a solace from the isolation imposed by his muteness.

As the mystery surrounding his father's death unravels, Edgar must confront the complex web of human relationships and the potentially devastating secrets that his family has kept. He navigates his own emotional turmoil, grappling with his father's legacy, the loss of his mother, and the implications of his own silence. The investigation leads him to confront not just the killer, but also the darker aspects of human nature, reflecting the themes of loyalty, betrayal, and the blurred line between human and animal connection.

Ultimately, the novel explores themes of communication, both verbal and nonverbal, the power of family bonds (and their failings), and the complex interplay between humans and animals. The narrative is both a compelling mystery and a poignant exploration of what it means to be human, highlighting the complexities of family, loyalty, and the enduring power of connection in the face of loss and betrayal.