Eligible: A Modern Retelling of Pride and Prejudice (The Austen Project, #4) Summary & Key Insights

Curtis Sittenfeld's "Eligible" offers a contemporary, Chicago-based reimagining of Jane Austen's "Pride and Prejudice." The Bennet sisters are replaced by the three attractive and intelligent Bennett sisters – Liz, Jane, and Kitty – living in a somewhat dysfunctional family. Liz, a cynical and ambitious journalist, is the central character, mirroring Elizabeth Bennet's sharp wit and independent spirit. Her older sister, Jane, a successful physician, embodies Jane Bennet's gentle nature, though with a modern twist of professional drive. Kitty, the youngest, is a struggling reality TV personality, representing a more contemporary, albeit less refined, version of the original Kitty. Their mother, a well-meaning but somewhat embarrassing social climber, still exerts a considerable influence, though her methods are updated for a 21st-century context.

The story centers on the arrival of the wealthy and eligible Chip Bingley, a neurosurgeon who moves into the neighborhood with his best friend, the brooding and socially awkward, but brilliant, Dr. Fitzwilliam Darcy. Chip, a charming and somewhat superficial man, quickly becomes infatuated with Jane, while Darcy, initially aloof and dismissive of the Bennet family, finds himself increasingly drawn to the independent and intellectually stimulating Liz.

Their relationship mirrors the original but with modern complexities. Liz initially dislikes Darcy, seeing him as arrogant and judgmental due to his perceived condescending attitude toward her family and professional ambitions. Darcy, in turn, is initially put off by Liz's skepticism and her perception of his wealth and status. Their interactions are fraught with misunderstandings amplified by social media and the pervasive nature of online information in the modern age.

The narrative explores contemporary issues alongside the classic themes. Liz's career struggles and the pressure to succeed in a competitive field, along with the challenges of navigating modern dating and social media, are interwoven with the timeless themes of class, societal expectations, and the complexities of love and relationships. The portrayal of the Bennet sisters' diverse paths, showcasing their distinct personalities and aspirations, adds another layer of depth to the story.

Throughout the novel, the clash between Liz and Darcy’s personalities, further complicated by their initial prejudices and preconceived notions, drives the plot forward. Misunderstandings, fueled by societal pressures and misinterpretations of actions, create obstacles in their potential relationship. Ultimately, however, both Liz and Darcy overcome their pride and prejudices, recognizing the value of each other’s strength and intelligence. The novel concludes with a reflection on personal growth, the importance of overcoming ingrained biases, and the ultimate triumph of love and understanding. Sittenfeld effectively modernizes the classic tale, retaining its charm and wit while adding a contemporary resonance.